2017 Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon vs 2018 Surly Ogre
The XL is the Surly Ogre size closest to your XL Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon. We match frame stack and reach. This is a geometry comparison, not a fit recommendation; stem, spacers, handlebars and saddle setup also affect your riding position.
What changes on the Surly Ogre
Compared with the Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon in XL, the Surly Ogre in XL places the top of the head tube 18 mm lower and 27 mm further forward, relative to the bottom bracket. Its wheelbase is 19 mm longer, which can contribute to stability at speed.
- Frame stack
- −18 mm
- Lower front end
- Frame reach
- +27 mm
- Longer frame reach
- Wheelbase
- +19 mm
- Longer: steadier at speed
- Head angle
- ±0.0°
- About the same head angle
- Chainstays
- +5 mm
- Longer: more planted
The two frames
Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon, XLSurly Ogre, XLDrawn to scale and lined up at the bottom bracket.
Geometry side by side
| Measurement | Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon XL | Surly Ogre XL | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reach | 420mm | 447 | +27 mm |
| Stack | 650mm | 632 | −18 mm |
| Head tube angle | 72° | 72.0° | ±0.0° |
| Seat tube angle | 73° | 73.0° | ±0.0° |
| Effective top tube | 619mm | 640 | +21 mm |
| Chainstay length | 435mm | 440 | +5 mm |
| Wheelbase | 1091mm | 1110 | +19 mm |
| BB drop | 70mm | 68 | −2 mm |
| BB height | 275mm | not listed | |
| Standover | 860.3mm | 857.85 | −2 mm |
| Seat tube length | 570mm | 558 | −12 mm |
| Fork length | 398mm | 447 | +49 mm |
| Head tube length | 225mm | 150 | −75 mm |
Differences are the Surly Ogre minus the Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon. Full charts: 2017 Specialized Sirrus Comp Carbon, 2018 Surly Ogre.
Where each sits in its class
Specialized Sirrus Comp CarbonSurly Ogre
Each bike is ranked against the other commuter bikes on Quiver, on frame geometry alone. Not your hand position or ride feel.
What each ships with
The stock build of each bike's first listed trim. Parts that match are dimmed.
| Part | Specialized Sirrus Comp CarbonComp Carbon | Surly OgreOgre |
|---|---|---|
| Derailleur | Shimano Tiagra 4700, Shimano Tiagra | Shimano Deore Front, Shimano Deore Rear |
| Chain | KMC X-10 | KMC X10 |
| Crankset | FSA Gossamer Pro | Shimano T551 |
| Bottom bracket | FSA MegaExo | SRAM PowerSpline |
| Wheelset | Specialized AXIS Elite | not listed |
| Tire | Specialized Espoir Sport Reflect | Surly Extraterrestrial |
| Brake | Shimano Alivio | Avid BB7, Tektro FR5 |
| Stem | Specialized Flowset | Kalloy AS-008 |
| Seatpost | Specialized Pro Pave | Kalloy SP-342 |
| Saddle | Specialized Canopy Comp | WTB Volt Sport |
| Frame | not listed | Surly Ogre |
| Shifter | not listed | Shimano Deore |
| Cassette | not listed | Shimano HG50 |
| Chainring | not listed | Shimano T551 |
| Rim | not listed | WTB i29 |
| Handlebar | not listed | Surly Moloko |
| Grips | not listed | Velo Black |
| Headset | not listed | Cane Creek 40 |
Know what is on every bike.
Add your bike to Quiver. Keep its parts, setup, and service history together, then share your build.
Explore the app
